Legislation Matters: How Policy Changes Shape the Fight Against Domestic Violence

Domestic violence, a pervasive issue affecting millions globally, transcends demographics, socioeconomic statuses, and borders. While community efforts, advocacy, and survivor resources are indispensable in addressing this epidemic, legislation stands as a cornerstone in protecting victims, preventing abuse, and holding offenders accountable. Laws are not static; they reflect the priorities and evolution of a society. In the fight against domestic violence, legislative frameworks have become a battleground for progress, with far-reaching implications for survivors and communities.

The Evolution of Domestic Violence Legislation

Historically, domestic violence was considered a private, familial matter, shielded from public scrutiny and legal intervention. It wasn’t until the latter half of the 20th century that societies began to recognize domestic violence as a systemic issue requiring governmental action. Landmark developments include:

1. The Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) in the United States (1994):

   • Signed into law by President Bill Clinton, VAWA was a groundbreaking piece of federal legislation that provided funding for survivor services, established the National Domestic Violence Hotline, and emphasized coordinated community responses. It was reauthorized several times, each iteration expanding protections, including those for marginalized groups like LGBTQ+ individuals, immigrants, and Native American women.

2. International Frameworks:

   • The Istanbul Convention (2011), a Council of Europe treaty, set the gold standard for addressing violence against women. It emphasized prevention, protection, prosecution, and integrated policies, urging signatories to align national laws with its comprehensive approach.

3. State-Level Progress:

   • Across nations, states and provinces have enacted their own laws to address gaps in federal legislation. Examples include restraining orders, mandatory arrest policies, and enhanced penalties for repeat offenders.

Key Areas Where Legislation Impacts Domestic Violence

1. Protective Orders and Immediate Safeguards

Protective orders (restraining orders) are among the most common legal tools used to shield survivors from abusers. They offer immediate protection by legally barring the perpetrator from contacting or approaching the survivor. Research shows that protective orders can significantly reduce instances of repeated violence, though enforcement remains inconsistent across jurisdictions.

2. Criminalization and Sentencing

Legal systems play a pivotal role in defining domestic violence as a criminal offense rather than a civil matter. Clear definitions of abuse including physical, emotional, financial, and technological are critical for prosecution. Enhanced sentencing laws for domestic violence offenses emphasize the gravity of the crime, deterring potential abusers and reinforcing societal condemnation.

3. Economic Justice and Housing Protections

Economic abuse, a form of domestic violence often overlooked, requires legislative remedies. Laws addressing wage garnishment, eviction protections for survivors, and financial restitution hold offenders accountable and empower survivors to rebuild their lives. Housing legislation, such as prohibiting landlords from evicting survivors solely due to their abuse history, has been a game-changer in stabilizing lives post-crisis.

4. Child Custody and Family Law

Custody battles are often weaponized by abusers, prolonging cycles of control. Laws prioritizing the safety of the survivor and child in custody decisions, mandating supervised visitation, and recognizing the impact of abuse on children ensure that legal proceedings do not retraumatize survivors.

5. Intersectional Protections

Legislation must address the unique challenges faced by marginalized communities, including undocumented immigrants, racial minorities, and LGBTQ+ individuals. Laws like the U visa in the U.S., which provides temporary legal status to undocumented survivors who assist in prosecution, exemplify how policy can bridge gaps in protection.

The Role of Advocacy in Legislative Change

Survivor advocacy and grassroots activism have historically driven legislative advancements. Organizations like the National Network to End Domestic Violence (NNEDV) and international coalitions have pushed for broader definitions of abuse, funding for shelters, and accountability for law enforcement agencies that fail to act. Public campaigns and survivor testimonies personalize the issue, influencing policymakers to prioritize domestic violence in legislative agendas.

Challenges in Implementation

Despite progress, gaps in enforcement and implementation undermine the effectiveness of even the most robust laws:

1. Law Enforcement Training:

   • Inconsistent training among police officers can lead to mishandled cases. For example, survivors may face arrest under dual-arrest policies when officers misinterpret mutual violence.

2. Judicial Bias:

   • Survivors often encounter skepticism in courtrooms, particularly in cases involving emotional or financial abuse, where evidence may be less tangible.

3. Funding Limitations:

   • Many laws remain unfunded mandates, leaving shelters, hotlines, and advocacy programs struggling to meet demand.

4. Cultural Stigma:

   • In societies where victim-blaming persists, survivors may hesitate to seek legal protection, fearing judgment or retaliation.

The Way Forward: Recommendations for Future Legislation

1. Expanding Definitions of Abuse

Legislation must evolve to include emerging forms of abuse, such as digital stalking and economic coercion. Comprehensive definitions empower survivors to seek justice for non-physical violence that is equally damaging.

2. Mandatory Training for Judicial and Law Enforcement Personnel

Ongoing education for judges, police officers, and prosecutors ensures a trauma-informed approach to handling cases. Training on implicit biases, survivor-centered questioning, and the dynamics of abuse can transform survivor experiences in the legal system.

3. Sustainable Funding Models

Governments must allocate consistent funding to domestic violence programs. Public-private partnerships can supplement governmental efforts, ensuring that shelters and hotlines remain accessible.

4. Global Cooperation

Domestic violence knows no borders. International treaties and cross-border agreements can address issues like trafficking, ensuring survivors receive protection regardless of nationality.

5. Integrating Technology for Survivors

Legislation should leverage technology to empower survivors. Confidential apps, secure communication platforms, and online restraining orders can provide lifesaving resources while safeguarding survivor privacy.

The Power of Policy in Shaping Lives

Legislation is more than a set of rules, it is a reflection of societal values and a tool for change. Each policy addressing domestic violence carries the potential to save lives, heal communities, and disrupt cycles of abuse. However, progress requires vigilance. Policymakers, advocates, and communities must work together to identify gaps, address systemic barriers, and push for equitable laws that uphold the dignity and safety of all.

Domestic violence is not inevitable; it is preventable. Through thoughtful, survivor-centered legislation, society can affirm its commitment to justice, equality, and the fundamental right to live free from fear.

---

Harmony House

The mission of Harmony House is to provide shelter, advocacy and education to survivors of domestic violence and promote the principle that all individuals have the right to life free of abuse.

Since 1976, our emergency shelter and supportive outreach case management programs have offered individuals and their children the opportunity to rest and heal both emotionally and physically in a supportive environment. We believe you. You are not alone and we can help!

If you or someone you know is living in an abusive situation, call 417–864-SAFE (7233) to speak with an advocate.

Click here to learn more about Harmony House